What is it about political campaigns that divides a nation? What happened to civil discourse? I was taught at St. Mary's Dominican High School in New Orleans, the rules of debate, and Robert's Rules of Order.
To be prepared for a debate in 1966 meant combing the card catalogues for days and weeks to find support for our positions.
Imagine this as a debating topic for high school students: Nuclear Proliferation?! There I was a 17 year old idealist handed a debate topic that terrified me! There were no internet research capabilities; just old magazines and newspapers stored on microfiche that had to be magnified to be read. There were no instance searches with cut and paste options; just a pen and a notebook.
And woe to you who had not prepared properly; you were decimated by your opponent! Debating had an order to it. One person spoke while the other LISTENED and took copious notes in order to prepare a rebuttal.
One person was not allowed to SHout over the other; that would have cost you seriously; that would have LOST the debate for you. I would not have wanted to face my debate coach if I had lost a debate because of improper procedure.
You were not allowed TO CAP SOMEONE OUT LOUD! Where has this originated? Thank God that we are not CAPPED OUTLOUD for our behavior.
No comments:
Post a Comment